The plant had added an in-house lab and treatment of its tap water. As it follows from our post, WaterWipes baby wipes contain benzalkonium chloride. And we have not talked about the cloth ingredients of the wipes. He would fight us so much when it was time to change his diaper, even if it was just wet, because his bottom hurt so bad. Thank you! newborn baby skin care: soft, smooth but incredibly sensitive. By the mid-1980s sales flattened, but stores soon asked the company to get into a promising new market: Disposable wipes. wrote to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, an FDA investigator visited Rockline's Arkansas plant, An FDA report noted that company leaders thought sanitation problems, Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. An FDA inspector overlooked key problems in the Arkansas plant in 2006. And rate them 1-10 or in an ordered list or better to worst? According to the same, only a few lot numbers were being recalled from stores. Here you will find a scientific comparison of the type and level of microbial contaminants in two kinds of products commercial cosmetics and a laboratory prepared aqueous cream. have you heard anything else- been using for a few days now- but want to make sure they do not contain anything like parabens , synthetics or triclosan still! Federal law says a cosmetic must not be "adulterated" - meaning made in unsanitary conditions - or have high levels of organisms on it. These complaints were from October 2014. At the time there seemed to be endocrine disruptor in every other brand! Just came back to your blog to see if there was any update about the wipes and Im really happy (and relieved) to see that there is nothing bad in these wipes! WebWaterWipes Biodegradable Original Baby Wipes (Select Count) WaterWipes. I confirm that I am over 16 years old and that I have reviewed and agree to the Terms and Conditions and have reviewed the Privacy Policy. Parents worry about the possible recall of these baby wipes with the ongoing formula shortage in the US, including Parents Choice Formula, following the massive Similac recall involving Cronobacter and Salmonella bacteria. The Hartland-based Triad Group was raided by federal agents in April and recalled sterile alcohol wipes used in hospitals and other products. Although it doesnt pose a medical risk to healthy people, it can cause serious health complications or bacterial infections for those with Thanks for your useful website. On the other hand, this also meant that there were no preservatives at all in the baby wipes, which was equally concerning to me. On October 4, the FDA announced that they had found unacceptable levels of benzene, acetaldehyde, and acetal contaminants in samples of the ArtNaturals scent-free hand sanitizer. It makes me wonder: has the concentration changed? We just discovered that my baby has a citrus allergy I had just identified it after scrutinizing my diet (I nurse), and that night my husband unknowingly used the first water wipe in a package we just bought to clean my babys neck and he got hives. You may want to wipe your hands clean of these hand sanitizer lots. "Sam Wilson was a very disgruntled employee," Rudolph said. Twitter user Presley Brookee posted a picture of a notice sent to all Walmart stores regarding the withdrawal of the baby wipes. Aveeno Baby 8. Industry experts contacted by the Journal Sentinel say the sky-high levels suggested poor manufacturing practices, filthy conditions or both. walmart has no recall for parents choice wipes yall, Just posting for any mommas who may not have seen- parents choice wipe recall, Parents choice wipes recall 2022 explained amid heavy metals and arsenic fears. Hi Irina, Are these wipes safe? There have been no recalls of products made in the Sheboygan plant, according to FDA records. for baby Our baby range are the world's purest baby wipes and purer than cotton wool and water. Read more here and here. Ron Johnson, a former FDA official hired by Rockline in the whistleblower lawsuit, told the Journal Sentinel that the company acted correctly during the 2006 recall. And who doesnt use a pack of baby wipes up within 4 weeks? "Wet wipes are not well-regulated, which has shown itself to be a problem as they are difficult to preserve as a product and difficult to manufacture in a sanitary manner," said Scott Sutton, a New York-based microbiologist who has worked as a consultant to cosmetic manufacturers for 25 years. You can withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the unsubscribe button in emails that you receive. All rights reserved. So, I can imagine your excitement and relief seeing water wipes for babies with just two ingredients! Wish they would be honest with the process some kids react to even small amounts of chlorine. Item model number : 980040803. We have used babyganics but in my latest shipment they were molded and smelled of chemicals. I cant imagine choosing these for my infant and never knowing that it would have such a strong tingling sensation and possibly cause him irritation. In September 2006, Rockline received a report from its outside lab that there wasBurkholderia cepaciaon its wipes,according to the company records. No serious injuries or illness have been definitively linked to the contaminated wipes. Natural GSE is good for skin conditioning, but I am not aware of any studies that conclusively demonstrate GSE as an effective preservative. Washcloths and pure water give her a rash too. Thank you for asking! 2023 I Read Labels For You. TheJournal of the American Academy of Dermatologydescribes cases of a fungal infection caused by a compromised skin lotion in patients. Our baby range are the world's purest baby wipes and purer than cotton wool and water. That bacterium threatens people with compromised immune systems, is antibiotic-resistant and can live even in alcohol solutions, according to Dave Warshauer, chief bacteriologist at the Wisconsin State Laboratory of Hygiene. "I can't imagine releasing without testing," said Phil Geis, a microbiologist who retired after three decades with Procter and Gamble. So, technically, there was a possibility that these water wipes for babies could remain free of bacteria and mold. So make sure that the hand sanitizer that you have purchased or are using arent part of the recall list. Thank you! Tests showed the presence of Burkholderia cepacia (B. cepacea). Conversely, there are studies showing that natural GSE does not have antimicrobial properties whatsoever. Well, back in March 24, Valisure, a company that tests and checks the composition of different health-related products, announced that they had found benzene in samples from 44 hand sanitizer products. TheJournal of Hospital Infectionreports numerous infections among 14 babies. They explained to me that the Grapefruit Seed Extract (GSE) in their water wipes for babies contained only three components. WebSheila G's Gluten Free Reeses Pieces Brownie Brittle - 3/23/2023. Rockline spokesman Evan Zeppos said Hickok was not allowed to make copies because of a policy that only employees can use company equipment such as a copy machine. Hazard: Fire, Burn, or Electrical Shock. You have JavaScript disabled in your browser. A subsequent lawsuit provided a rare view into the wipes maker's operations by making public a series of internal Rockline documents. Pampers Sensitive 6. But you are not likely to get such levels of exposure even if you are bathing in or covering yourself head-to-toe in hand sanitizer so that you look like a glazed doughnut. Rockline has not alerted the public about the latest recall. Lets talk about why I had my reservations about the safety of the grapefruit seed extract to begin with. $3.59 - $45.99. Snopestionary: What Is Copypasta? Snopes.Com, https://www.snopes.com/articles/369246/what-is-copypasta/. Wilson wrote back that the private investigator hired by Rockline had interviewed employees and done handwriting analysis and computer searches. I will contact WaterWipes about their water. "This occurred and the industry said, 'We need to tighten things up.' The official Walmart website has not stated that the product has been removed from shelves. Potentially contaminated wipes were making it to market because the company routinely shipped them before the results of lab testing were available, according to FDA and company documents. Recalled Product: WAYNE WaterBUG GLOW Multi-Use Pump sold between July 2019March 2021. Rockline officials said they put consumer safety first and denied they knowingly shipped contaminated products. Hi, Kate: may I ask what is the source of your information? Some products may have inappropriate ingredients too. Please, refer to the list here: https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/best-baby-wipes-rating-list-ebook/, Consumer Safety Advocate & Manufacturer Advisor For Ingredient Safety. And he said the plant's use of tap water and its policy to ship before receiving test results were accepted industry practices, despite what the experts told the Journal Sentinel. Disposable wipes are used for everything from combating infectious diseases to cleaning up household messes. Did the FDA act quickly on this letter from Valisure? Thanks. Lets look at this ingredient in the WaterWipes baby wipes in detail. These wipes were the closest thing I could find to what they used in the hospital and I absolutely love them. top tips for moms and dads on exercising at home. Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. The press releases provide the steps you should take if you have purchased one of the recalled items. Health, Center for Devices and Radiological. Rockline founder Ralph Rudolph, father of Randy, was a pilot for the German military during World War II before he immigrated to the United States after the war, by his own account. What a truly wonderful product, I strongly recommend to all mothers, pleas try them! Do you have any information on their? Our original baby wipes, with one major improvement: they are now plastic free*. Yes, I was forwarded the U.S. Patent application #20110203946 by someone who had worked in the industry. Thank you for letting me know! 1995 - 2023 by Snopes Media Group Inc. The Rockline baby wipe tested by FDA showed 97 million to 190 million parts per gram - thousands of times over that recommended level. This is good to know, i came across this as i was trying to do my own research on the waterwipes brand. WebA list of 63 baby wipes with ratings from the safest to the least safe. "It is contaminated. When benzene cause your bone marrow to produce abnormal cells, the result can be leukemia. No problem with mould nor bacterial infections on his bottom, though I was always conscious of the lack of preservatives in these wipes so now that were using less of them we only have one pack opened at once and finish it well within 4 weeks. "You just can't control everything unless maybe it's a sealed plant that is building microchips," he said. Customers may return the product to any Walmart store for a refund. Im wondering if its the wipes?! In 1989, the family-run company bought a plant owned by Midwest Converting in Springdale, Ark. However, the only public notice of the current recall has been an item buried deep in the FDA website. This is what I learned in 2014. Thank you for the question! I do not trust this company , I emailed them directly because my baby broke out from wipes, they would not show me evidence of test results- something seems shady. Later, we got a box of Costco Kirkland baby wipes. Over 15 years, the Arkansas plant expanded from a $5 million-a-year operation to one that brought in more than $150 million in revenue, according to court documents. We have never experienced any problems with them and I love that they are pure and simple. Irish Breeze claimed that WaterWipes baby wipes were preserved with a patented preservation system that resulted in a sterile product before the wipe pack was open. It returned only after receiving the whistleblower letter. Despite the whistleblower's warning and serious problems found in the Arkansas plant, Rockline's flagship plant in Sheboygan was last inspected in 1992. Wilson asked if it was legal to take DNA and wondered in an email what Wal-Mart would think. Hi Irina, It was listed in Rockline's internal lab results - which the inspector could not copy. Our adult hygiene wipes are conveniently large and textured for softness, with specially purified water to safely care for the most delicate skin. 155 Fleet Street, When it comes to baby wipes, Congress has left the FDA largely toothless. Seventh Generation 11. You might look into downloading my Baby Wipes Rating List as well: https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/best-baby-wipes-rating-list-ebook/ ~Irina. I have been using these WaterWipes for 18 months. They are still ideal for sensitive, newborn and premature babys skin and contain only two ingredients, 99.9% water and a drop of fruit extract. He would scream and cry and hold on to us as tight as he could. I am currently using water wipes but if they are not the best and healthiest option i would like to change, but dont want to spend money on the e-book if i cant readily purchase the recommended wipes. An email with the subject line Dept. One can locate the lot numbers on the upper front portion of the box. Recalls, Corrections and Removals (Devices). FDA, 17 Mar. But FDA documents do not even mention that bacterium. Enfamil Simply Plant-Based Infant Formula - 2/20/2023. Why Were Huggies Wipes Recalled? Using water and a wipe might work sufficiently if the baby peed only. All of these 10 lots include eight ounce bottles of the product, bear a Universal Product Code (UPC) of 816820028205, and have an expiration date of May 1, 2022. Soap and water can be much more effective at washing off nasty microbes. Did you know about this? Now lets talk about why I wanted to make sure that these wet wipes do have a sufficient preservation system. When I do my product research, I do not rely on manufacturers claims of safety. It can also affect your marrows ability to produce white blood cells, the guardians of your immune system. The whistleblowers were ultimately fired. That kind of defiance has landed other companies in trouble with the FDA, according to Marcia Crosse, head of health care for the General Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress. If we even mentioned the word diaper he would run screaming at the top of his lungs. Randy Rudolph told the newspaper that Wilson was an unstable man who tried to hurt the company, and his letter to FDA was riddled with inaccuracies. We even tried Viva paper towels and pure water and she got a rash. Im desperate to find a wipe that is ever so gentle but that will clean her bottom without having to wipe hard or irritate her in anyway. The recalled products may contain bacteria, including Pseudomonas aeruginosa, an environmental organism found widely in soil and water. Those documents show Rockline was receiving a stream of customer complaints about mold in 2006. WebProduct Recall FAQ How will I be informed if there has been a recall? And your right you really have to be careful to keep them clean especially with a fussy baby thats pooped or peed. The plant made moist towelettes and baby wipes for private label customers. WebPackage recycling varies across the different materials used. Weakening your immune system can in turn allow more infections, which is the exact opposite of what hand sanitizer is supposed to do. "I am damn proud of what we do here. The step-by-step instructions on the GSE production process they described made sense to me. Generally, in baby wipes purified or filtered water is used. Baby on the way? An Arizton Advisory and Intelligence report estimated that the market for hand sanitizers has grown by 595% since 2019. 4 May 2022, https://web.archive.org/web/20220504144710/https:/community.babycenter.com/post/a77720658/parents-choice-baby-wipes-recall. He worked as a janitor when he arrived, later rising to vice president of a Sheboygan-area factory before the plant moved and he was laid off. Amazon Elements 7. I figure, if the hospital uses only water on micro preemies, it must be the best thing. A jury found in Wilson's favor last year, on both complaints. ~Irina. According to a U.S. Food Drug Administration (FDA) announcement, ArtNaturals has issued a voluntary recall of ten lots of its Scent-Free Hand Sanitizer. The Miami Herald did report on May 4 that at least 18 lots of the wipes were pulled by the box retailer for an unannounced reason. b belle2525 Feb 16, 2021 at 5:48 PM last month I ordered wipes from Amazon. All hand sanitizers are not the same. Experts said such a high contamination level qualifies as "adulterated," a violation of the cosmetics law. Add to cart. What are your thoughts on using wipe warmers with Watervwipes? The FDA has returned and found fresh problems, but once again hasn't taken any enforcement action. Hi Laura: this is awful. For your baby, I recommend this: https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/dry-baby-wipes-safe-for-your-baby/ ~Irina. WaterWipes gently cleans and helps protect skin. Best Sellers Rank: #159,959 in Health & Household ( See Top 100 in Health & Household) #264 in Personal Cleansing Wipes. When purchased online. Kimberly-Clark announced a recall of some its Cottonelle Flushable Wipes products. We promise not to send you any junk. Claim: Several brands of baby wipes available in the U.S. were recalled in 2017 because they pose a risk of serious infection. In addition, they said that there was no food in the wipes for germs to grow, even after the opening of the pack. They are still ideal for sensitive, newborn and premature babys skin and contain only two ingredients, 99.9% water and a drop of fruit extract. Neither has publicly issued an official statement pertaining to the Parent's Choice baby wipes. The labels also state DISTRIBUTED BY THE KROGER CO, CINCINNATI, OHIO 45202. Baby wipes are made from non-woven paper material that is soaked in water, with a small amount of sanitizer and preservative. Im interested to see if any microbial tests over time after opening have been carried out? This research assessed the microbial properties and the antibiotic sensitivity patterns of 15 random cosmetic products. NH 03801 USA. Hickok wrote in her inspection report that the firm used tap water without additional filtration or treatment. wipes were sold in the cleaning supplies section of stores instead of with the personal care and hand sanitizer products in the health and beauty aisle, the suit alleges. Get the latest on new products and stories from our community. In a world of more noise, choices and advice, less can be more. Have you or anyone else queried this at all? Ogden would only say in a phone interview that everything in her deposition was true. Your membership is the foundation of our sustainability and resilience. To read our affiliate policy, click here. Irish Breeze was the name of the wipes manufacturing company. I was not confident that the sterility remained when the product was being used. So I returned (finding out many others had same issues) and bought some Honest Company Wipes. The wipes are textured for better cleaning. Melissa. Your email address will not be published. They said as soon as they knew there was a problem they took action. So thus far we continue to use them. The FDA has not inspected several thousand drug and device makers in at least five years, and hundreds of plants have not seen an inspector in a decade. They now contain grapefruit seed extract and soapberry extract. Wilson and Jacques were fired in early 2008. Honest Company 3. Join our informed consumer community and get our free guide the 5 Powerful Steps To A Non-Toxic Home. Replies to my comments We use them as the package directions indicate which has not been a problem for us. The company eventually expanded to six plants - four in the United States, one in China and one in England - and raced to the forefront of a billion-dollar industry. You can withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the unsubscribe button in emails that you receive. Kim McCarthy, a Kenosha County mother of a baby girl, unknowingly used two of the products on the current recall list. Ogden,Slank's assistant, was fired with Wilson and the other whistleblower after they were accused of violating the company's email policy by making unprofessional comments about supervisors. The arsenic and mercury rumors did not originate with a reliable source and, as of this writing, are entirely unconfirmed. Keep in mind that in general, healthy people are used to their own bacteria including what is in their poop and dont get sick from it, aside from it entering the urinary tract. Therefore, it looks like unacceptable levels of benzene somehow got into the hand sanitizer during the manufacturing processes used by the factories in China that make these ArtNaturals products. Please logout and login again. You may opt-out by. On the one hand, I applaud the manufacturer for disclosing a full list of ingredients. They sent the whistleblower letter to the FDA in October 2006. While this study identified benzethonium chloride in commercial grapefruit seed extracts, this one found benzalkonium chloride in GSE. This just proves my theory that their preservation system is not sufficient to be safe. In addition, they said that there was no food in the wipes for germs to grow, even after the opening of the pack. I'm so glad you're here! Great suggestion, Melissa! Parents around the country use baby wipes on their infants and young toddlers many times a day, never suspecting that these products may be unsanitary or unsafe for use on a babys or childs skin. But on the other hand, this additional ingredient raises concerns. WebTop 5 Baby Wipes Comparison Table 1. Irish Breeze claimed that WaterWipes baby wipes were preserved with a patented preservation system that resulted in a sterile product before the wipe pack was open. I am not a big fan of preservatives as most of them have some controversy around them. WebFamilies can trust WaterWipes Original baby wipes 540 count (9 packs) to gently clean and help protect sensitive skin. I liked the ingredients of these, and that they lacked the usual preservatives. No FDA inspector returned to the plant. The company pledged to do a better job keeping the plant clean. Snopes readers sent our team the following screenshots as examples of the types of social media posts they were seeing online: As of this writing, Snopes has not been able to independently verify whether a recall had been issued by either Walmart or the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the governmental agency that oversees product recalls, corrections, and removals. I have been using Water Wipes since my baby was born 9 months ago. We never had a single problem with diaper rash until I brought him home and started using store-bought wipes; even with the sensitive skin ones it was just awful. our products. NH 03801 USA. We are trusted, non-toxic consumer product researchers on a mission to help you make informed decisions about the products you buy. There also were reports of rashes and infections possibly due to the wipes. Other non-sterile products, such as baby wipes, are regulated as cosmetics and are subject to less oversight. 30 Apr. Thats not all. But I personally would not feel comfortable using these water wipes for babies on my child. It typically takes repeated exposure over a longer period of time (e.g., over a year) to such levels of benzene to cause problems. I have seen every cash pay doctor, had 2 biopsies, ultrasounds, a pelvic MRI, and most recently had a Patch Testing on my back at Mayo Clinic. You may have been in a situation when you wanted to do something fast but ended up spending hours and sometimes even without any result. UPC : 078742206356. Portsmouth, They are wonderful and I personally wouldnt be concerned about any of the potential issues mentioned here. Rumors of Parents Choice Baby Wipes being recalled have made rounds on the internet. "You would lose control.". It discovered that most of the creams and lotions in question did not meet the official requirements. Surely those should be done before they are for sale but, like you Im worried about harmful bacteria and fungi growing on them. Well, not any longer. WebTo make the worlds purest baby wipes, we use as few ingredients as possible and a unique 7 stage water purification process that offers a deeper and more effective clean compared to standard tap water or boiled, cooled tap water. It can affect your marrows ability to produce red blood cells, which in turn can lead to anemia and abnormal bleeding. WaterWipes baby wet wipes remain the world's purest baby wipes, but are now plastic free*. We promise not to send you any junk. Thanks for your information. As the FDA investigated Rockline's 2006 contamination, the hunt was launched in the Arkansas plant for the whistleblowers. Benzene doesnt really serve any hand-cleaning purposes either. Make sure that the hand sanitizer doesnt appear on the FDAs do not use list. - Citrus Grandis (grapefruit) seed extract*. Hi, do you know if the Honest baby wipes are ok? New York-based Professional Disposables International is in the midst of its own recall of alcohol prep wipes because of bacterial contamination. Our new Plastic-Free Original wipes are the same formula and purity as before, with just 2 ingredients: 99.9% ultra-purified water and a drop of fruit extract to naturally cleanse the skin. We havent had a single problem since we started using them. All According to a U.S. Food Drug Administration (FDA) announcement, ArtNaturals has issued a voluntary recall of ten lots of its Scent-Free Hand Sanitizer. Moreover, the Wipe Out! "Contamination doesn't seem like something I should have to worry about, but obviously there is cause for concern," she said. But if i touch one under the first that i grabbed i grab it and use it immediately just to be sure shes getting the cleanest wipe next. But there are no rules governing baby wipes manufacturers, only suggestions. He said it was the first major recall in the country of baby wipes for bacteria. In this study researchers examined the antimicrobial efficacy and the content of preservative agents of six commercially available grapefruit seed extracts. He noted the law did not require it. But I cant afford to test the baby wipes on my son to bring the results to the publics attention.
Love Nikki Suits To Craft,
Tullahoma Funeral Home Obituaries,
Miguel Cervantes Hamilton Height,
Articles W